Product Comparisons

 

Elko® GuttaGard™ Product Comparison

inexpensive gutter protection imageThere are dozens of gutter protection products on the market today, ranging from inexpensive screens to expensive filters and high-profile domed products. There are just as many performance claims and misleading warranties. It is truly a "Buyers Beware" market. For more on this, please ask for a copy of our free Consumer Guide to the Gutter Protection Industry.

Before you make a purchase decision, ask yourself a few key questions:

  • How easy is the product to install?
  • How easy is the product to clean and maintain?
  • Can the product be easily removed to clean the gutters if they do become clogged, as most eventually do?
  • Does the product require holes, nails or screws in your roof?
  • Will the product withstand weather, critters and other factors?
  • What is the installed cost of the product?

We're confident that once your evaluation is complete, the answer will be clear. Elko® GuttaGard™ is the most affordable, most effective product for your home.

Category
Product Names
Difficulty of Installation
Estimated Cost /Foot
Nails or Screw into Roof
Profile Description
Availability
Material
Potential Issues
Screens and Mesh
Gutterworld, Gutter Shingle, Drop-In, Snap-In, Lock-In, Sentinel and others
Easy to install by DIY homeowner
<$1/foot for DIY
No
Low Profile
Widely available in most home improvement stores
Vinyl and aluminum
Clogs easily; Debris accumulation, Dislodges in snow and ice
Filters and Perforated Panels
Leaf Relief, MasterShield, Gutter Screener, Invisiguard, LeafSolution, LeafFilter, Grater Gutter Guard
Requires professional installation
$6-35/ft. installed
No
Low Profile
Available through Authorized Dealers or through Contractors
Aluminum (Leaf Relief, MasterShield) and Vinyl (others)
Expensive, debris accumulation, clogs, mesh filter dislodges, flimsy, misleading warranties for interior clogs only
Vinyl Solid Gutter Guards
Waterfall, Cinch, Gutter Shut
Easy to install by DIY homeowner or contractor
$6-8/foot installed or $1.75-2.00 for DIY
No
Low Profile
Available online or at many home improvement stores
Vinyl
Vinyl degrades over time, critters can chew into system,Clogs Easily

Brushes, foam fillers

GutterBrush, GutterFilter
Rainflow,
Gutter Pillar,
Leaf Defier
Easy to install by DIY homeowner
$2-5/ft.
No
Low Profile
Available at many home improvement stores
Plastic or polyurethane foam
Clogs easily and quickly, debris accumulation,
All-in-One Gutters and Gutter Guards
LeafGuard, K-Guard, Leafaway
Complex installation by exclusive dealer
$14-22/ft.
No
High Profile
Available only through "authorized dealers"
Aluminum
Will clog, expensive, seamless -if damaged expensive to repair, requires replacement of existing gutters
Louvered Gutter Guards
Waterloov, Gutter Protech
Complex installation by franchise
$12-15/ft.
Yes
High Profile
Available only through "authorized dealers"
Aluminum
Expensive, louvers will clog and require cleaning
High profile, nose-forward Gutter Guards
Gutter Helmet, Gutter Cap, Gutter Topper
Complex installation by franchise
$12-20/ft.
Yes
High Profile
Available only through "authorized dealers"
Aluminum
Expensive, will clog, misleading warranties
Low profile, solid aluminum Gutter Guards
LeafProof, Leaf Free, Hallett Gutter Cover
Installation by contractor
$8-12/ft.
No
Low
profile
Available through contractors only
Aluminum
Expensive, difficult to clean gutters when they eventually clog, spotty follow up
Gutter Genius®
Installation by certified Elko installer
$5-8/ft.
No
Low
profile
Available through dealers only
Aluminum
10 Year warranty only valid if installed by certified Elko installer; will eventually clog

Elko® GuttaGard™
Gutter Genius® DIY™
Simple DIY installation or easy contractor installation
$1.65/ft. for DIY

$4-5/ft. for contractor installation

No
Low
profile
Widely available at hardware and home improvement stores or through contractors
Aluminum
Clips can become dislodged if not installed properly
Category
Product Names
Difficulty of Installation
Estimated Cost /Foot
Nails or Screw into Roof
Profile Description
Availability
Material
Potential Issues
Elko Products Company, Inc.; 9411 Burge Avenue, Richmond, VA 23237: Telephone: (804) 275-0050: Fax: (804) 275-0035

All GuttaGard™ products are made in the USA